IN-STORE SHOPPING HOURS: Mon–Sat: 10 AM-6 PM Sun: Closed CONSIGNMENT INTAKE HOURS: Mon–Sat: 10 AM-4 PM Sun: Closed
WOMEN'S SHOES - Too Good To Be Threw

WOMEN'S SHOES

Channel your inner Carrie Bradshaw and enjoy the thrill of finding designer shoes without breaking the bank. Too Good To Be Threw Consignment has a wide selection for everyone from flats to heels, wedges to boots. With expertly trained staff who know all about their brands so you can feel confident in every purchase!

Shop for your favorite brands of shoes at reduced prices in our consignment store. We stock women's designer heels, flats, sandals, designer shoes and boots from your favorite designers like BCBG MAX AZRIA, Michael Kors and Tory Burch. 

Filters

Product type
Size
More options
Brand
More options
Color
More options
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Condition
Slide image
DONALD J PLINER SILVER HEEL KNEE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK SILVER 8.5
DONALD J PLINER SILVER HEEL KNEE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK SILVER 8.5
DONALD J PLINER SILVER HEEL KNEE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK SILVER 8.5
Save 40%

DONALD J PLINER SILVER HEEL KNEE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK SILVER 8.5

$72.57 $120.95
Slide image
DONALD J PLINER KNEE SUEDE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK 8M
DONALD J PLINER KNEE SUEDE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK 8M
DONALD J PLINER KNEE SUEDE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK 8M
Save 40%

DONALD J PLINER KNEE SUEDE DESIGNER BOOTS BLACK 8M

$72.57 $120.95
Slide image
ONE432 RET$285 SLIP ON STARS DESIGNER SHOES BLACK GOLD 7
ONE432 RET$285 SLIP ON STARS DESIGNER SHOES BLACK GOLD 7
ONE432 RET$285 SLIP ON STARS DESIGNER SHOES BLACK GOLD 7
Save 20%

ONE432 RET$285 SLIP ON STARS DESIGNER SHOES BLACK GOLD 7

$96.76 $120.95
Slide image
RET. $395 TOGO STRIPE SLIDES DESIGNER SHOES RED YELLOW 7
RET. $395 TOGO STRIPE SLIDES DESIGNER SHOES RED YELLOW 7
RET. $395 TOGO STRIPE SLIDES DESIGNER SHOES RED YELLOW 7
Save 20%

RET. $395 TOGO STRIPE SLIDES DESIGNER SHOES RED YELLOW 7

$93.56 $116.95
Slide image
JIMMY CHOO MONOGRAM POOL SLIDES SHOES WHITE 39
JIMMY CHOO MONOGRAM POOL SLIDES SHOES WHITE 39
JIMMY CHOO MONOGRAM POOL SLIDES SHOES WHITE 39

JIMMY CHOO MONOGRAM POOL SLIDES SHOES WHITE 39

$100.95
Slide image
KATE SPADE FLAT RHINESTONES SANDALS SHOES BRONZE BROWN 8.5M
KATE SPADE FLAT RHINESTONES SANDALS SHOES BRONZE BROWN 8.5M
KATE SPADE FLAT RHINESTONES SANDALS SHOES BRONZE BROWN 8.5M
Save 20%

KATE SPADE FLAT RHINESTONES SANDALS SHOES BRONZE BROWN 8.5M

$42.36 $52.95
Slide image
JW ANDERSON LEATHER STRAPPY HEEL SHOES CREAM 37
JW ANDERSON LEATHER STRAPPY HEEL SHOES CREAM 37
JW ANDERSON LEATHER STRAPPY HEEL SHOES CREAM 37
Save 20%

JW ANDERSON LEATHER STRAPPY HEEL SHOES CREAM 37

$83.96 $104.95
Slide image
COLE HAAN PYTHON SANDAL WEDGE SHOES CREME GREY 7.5
COLE HAAN PYTHON SANDAL WEDGE SHOES CREME GREY 7.5
COLE HAAN PYTHON SANDAL WEDGE SHOES CREME GREY 7.5
Save 20%

COLE HAAN PYTHON SANDAL WEDGE SHOES CREME GREY 7.5

$36.76 $45.95
Slide image
SOREL SLIP ON SANDAL SHOES GRAY 8
SOREL SLIP ON SANDAL SHOES GRAY 8
SOREL SLIP ON SANDAL SHOES GRAY 8
Save 20%

SOREL SLIP ON SANDAL SHOES GRAY 8

$22.36 $27.95
Slide image
UGG ESPADRILLE WEDGE SANDAL SHOES NAVY 7
UGG ESPADRILLE WEDGE SANDAL SHOES NAVY 7
UGG ESPADRILLE WEDGE SANDAL SHOES NAVY 7
Save 20%

UGG ESPADRILLE WEDGE SANDAL SHOES NAVY 7

$42.36 $52.95
Slide image
GIANNI BINI HEEL LACE UP SANDALS SHOES VIOLET 11M
GIANNI BINI HEEL LACE UP SANDALS SHOES VIOLET 11M
GIANNI BINI HEEL LACE UP SANDALS SHOES VIOLET 11M
Save 20%

GIANNI BINI HEEL LACE UP SANDALS SHOES VIOLET 11M

$36.76 $45.95
Slide image
LOEFFLER RANDALL HEEL SUEDE KNOT SHOES PINK 5B
LOEFFLER RANDALL HEEL SUEDE KNOT SHOES PINK 5B
LOEFFLER RANDALL HEEL SUEDE KNOT SHOES PINK 5B
Save 20%

LOEFFLER RANDALL HEEL SUEDE KNOT SHOES PINK 5B

$28.76 $35.95
Slide image
MELISSA BOW JELLY SANDAL SHOES PINK 6
MELISSA BOW JELLY SANDAL SHOES PINK 6
MELISSA BOW JELLY SANDAL SHOES PINK 6
Save 20%

MELISSA BOW JELLY SANDAL SHOES PINK 6

$26.36 $32.95
Slide image
DIESEL FLORAL PEEP TOE SHOES WHITE PINK 5
DIESEL FLORAL PEEP TOE SHOES WHITE PINK 5
DIESEL FLORAL PEEP TOE SHOES WHITE PINK 5
Save 20%

DIESEL FLORAL PEEP TOE SHOES WHITE PINK 5

$31.96 $39.95
Slide image
MICHAEL MICHAEL KORS LOGO HEEL ANKLE STRAP SHOES YELLOW 6.5M
MICHAEL MICHAEL KORS LOGO HEEL ANKLE STRAP SHOES YELLOW 6.5M
MICHAEL MICHAEL KORS LOGO HEEL ANKLE STRAP SHOES YELLOW 6.5M
Save 20%

MICHAEL MICHAEL KORS LOGO HEEL ANKLE STRAP SHOES YELLOW 6.5M

$26.36 $32.95
Slide image
P448 RET$182 RAINBOW SNEAKER SHOES WHITE PINK 6
P448 RET$182 RAINBOW SNEAKER SHOES WHITE PINK 6
P448 RET$182 RAINBOW SNEAKER SHOES WHITE PINK 6
Save 20%

P448 RET$182 RAINBOW SNEAKER SHOES WHITE PINK 6

$44.76 $55.95
Slide image
BIBI LOU HEEL SANDAL SHOES WHITE 10
BIBI LOU HEEL SANDAL SHOES WHITE 10
BIBI LOU HEEL SANDAL SHOES WHITE 10
Save 20%

BIBI LOU HEEL SANDAL SHOES WHITE 10

$44.76 $55.95
Slide image
MARION PARKE "CORA SLIDE" W/ BOX DESIGNER SHOES ROSE 8.5B
MARION PARKE "CORA SLIDE" W/ BOX DESIGNER SHOES ROSE 8.5B
MARION PARKE "CORA SLIDE" W/ BOX DESIGNER SHOES ROSE 8.5B
Save 20%

MARION PARKE "CORA SLIDE" W/ BOX DESIGNER SHOES ROSE 8.5B

$75.16 $93.95
Slide image
KURT GEIGER METALLIC POOL SLIDE SHOES PINK WHITE 8
KURT GEIGER METALLIC POOL SLIDE SHOES PINK WHITE 8
KURT GEIGER METALLIC POOL SLIDE SHOES PINK WHITE 8
Save 20%

KURT GEIGER METALLIC POOL SLIDE SHOES PINK WHITE 8

$79.96 $99.95
Loading...