IN-STORE SHOPPING HOURS: Mon–Sat: 10 AM-6 PM Sun: Closed CONSIGNMENT INTAKE HOURS: Mon–Sat: 10 AM-4 PM Sun: Closed
WOMEN'S SHOES - Too Good To Be Threw

WOMEN'S SHOES

Channel your inner Carrie Bradshaw and enjoy the thrill of finding designer shoes without breaking the bank. Too Good To Be Threw Consignment has a wide selection for everyone from flats to heels, wedges to boots. With expertly trained staff who know all about their brands so you can feel confident in every purchase!

Shop for your favorite brands of shoes at reduced prices in our consignment store. We stock women's designer heels, flats, sandals, designer shoes and boots from your favorite designers like BCBG MAX AZRIA, Michael Kors and Tory Burch. 

Filters

Product type
Size
More options
Brand
More options
Color
More options
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Condition
Slide image
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES WHITE 8.5
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES WHITE 8.5
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES WHITE 8.5
New

JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES WHITE 8.5

$58.95
Slide image
PEDRO GARCIA RET$575 SUEDE PLATFORM SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES TAUPE ROSEGOLD 38
PEDRO GARCIA RET$575 SUEDE PLATFORM SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES TAUPE ROSEGOLD 38
PEDRO GARCIA RET$575 SUEDE PLATFORM SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES TAUPE ROSEGOLD 38
New

PEDRO GARCIA RET$575 SUEDE PLATFORM SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES TAUPE ROSEGOLD 38

$224.95
Slide image
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES BROWN 8.5
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES BROWN 8.5
JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES BROWN 8.5
New

JOHNSTON & MURPHY LEATHER MULE FLAT SHOES BROWN 8.5

$58.95
Slide image
AEROSOLES RET$135 PLATFORM SANDAL SHOES SILVER 8.5
AEROSOLES RET$135 PLATFORM SANDAL SHOES SILVER 8.5
AEROSOLES RET$135 PLATFORM SANDAL SHOES SILVER 8.5
New

AEROSOLES RET$135 PLATFORM SANDAL SHOES SILVER 8.5

$45.95
Slide image
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER PUMP SHOES BROWN 7.5
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER PUMP SHOES BROWN 7.5
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER PUMP SHOES BROWN 7.5
New

STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER PUMP SHOES BROWN 7.5

$78.95
Slide image
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER KITTEN FLAT DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 7.5N
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER KITTEN FLAT DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 7.5N
STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER KITTEN FLAT DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 7.5N
New

STUART WEITZMAN LEATHER KITTEN FLAT DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 7.5N

$124.95
Slide image
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES BLUE BROWN 7
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES BLUE BROWN 7
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES BLUE BROWN 7
New

NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES BLUE BROWN 7

$25.95
Slide image
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES PINK BROWN 7
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES PINK BROWN 7
NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES PINK BROWN 7
New

NATURALIZER LEATHER WEDGE SHOES PINK BROWN 7

$25.95
Slide image
ADIDAS SUEDE SNEAKER SHOES GRAY WHITE 8.5
ADIDAS SUEDE SNEAKER SHOES GRAY WHITE 8.5
ADIDAS SUEDE SNEAKER SHOES GRAY WHITE 8.5
New

ADIDAS SUEDE SNEAKER SHOES GRAY WHITE 8.5

$49.95
Slide image
AIR JORDAN "UNC" LEATHER LOW SNEAKER SHOES BLUE WHITE 8
AIR JORDAN "UNC" LEATHER LOW SNEAKER SHOES BLUE WHITE 8
AIR JORDAN "UNC" LEATHER LOW SNEAKER SHOES BLUE WHITE 8
New

AIR JORDAN "UNC" LEATHER LOW SNEAKER SHOES BLUE WHITE 8

$75.95
Slide image
MIZUNO VOLLEYBALL SNEAKER SHOES BLACK SILVER 8.5
MIZUNO VOLLEYBALL SNEAKER SHOES BLACK SILVER 8.5
MIZUNO VOLLEYBALL SNEAKER SHOES BLACK SILVER 8.5
New

MIZUNO VOLLEYBALL SNEAKER SHOES BLACK SILVER 8.5

$38.95
Slide image
MARC FISHER WEDGE SANDAL SHOES WHITE 6.5
MARC FISHER WEDGE SANDAL SHOES WHITE 6.5
MARC FISHER WEDGE SANDAL SHOES WHITE 6.5
New

MARC FISHER WEDGE SANDAL SHOES WHITE 6.5

$19.95
Slide image
PLATFORM SNEAKER SHOES BLUE TAN 7
PLATFORM SNEAKER SHOES BLUE TAN 7
PLATFORM SNEAKER SHOES BLUE TAN 7
New

PLATFORM SNEAKER SHOES BLUE TAN 7

$29.95
Slide image
ON CLOUD RET$199 LACE UP SNEAKERS SHOES BLUE NAVY 8
ON CLOUD RET$199 LACE UP SNEAKERS SHOES BLUE NAVY 8
ON CLOUD RET$199 LACE UP SNEAKERS SHOES BLUE NAVY 8
New

ON CLOUD RET$199 LACE UP SNEAKERS SHOES BLUE NAVY 8

$88.95
Slide image
STEVE MADDEN FLAT SANDAL SHOES SILVER GOLD 7
STEVE MADDEN FLAT SANDAL SHOES SILVER GOLD 7
STEVE MADDEN FLAT SANDAL SHOES SILVER GOLD 7
New

STEVE MADDEN FLAT SANDAL SHOES SILVER GOLD 7

$15.95
Slide image
J. CREW FLAT MULE SHOES BROWN BLACK 7
J. CREW FLAT MULE SHOES BROWN BLACK 7
J. CREW FLAT MULE SHOES BROWN BLACK 7
New

J. CREW FLAT MULE SHOES BROWN BLACK 7

$18.95
Slide image
J. CREW FLAT SANDAL SHOES GREEN 7
J. CREW FLAT SANDAL SHOES GREEN 7
J. CREW FLAT SANDAL SHOES GREEN 7
New

J. CREW FLAT SANDAL SHOES GREEN 7

$14.95
Slide image
MIA HEEL SLIDE SHOES CREAM RED 6
MIA HEEL SLIDE SHOES CREAM RED 6
MIA HEEL SLIDE SHOES CREAM RED 6
New

MIA HEEL SLIDE SHOES CREAM RED 6

$14.95
Slide image
SCHUTZ HEEL PUMP SHOES TAN CLEAR 5
SCHUTZ HEEL PUMP SHOES TAN CLEAR 5
SCHUTZ HEEL PUMP SHOES TAN CLEAR 5
New

SCHUTZ HEEL PUMP SHOES TAN CLEAR 5

$89.95
Slide image
COLE HAAN TASSEL LOAFERS SHOES BROWN BLACK 11
COLE HAAN TASSEL LOAFERS SHOES BROWN BLACK 11
COLE HAAN TASSEL LOAFERS SHOES BROWN BLACK 11
New

COLE HAAN TASSEL LOAFERS SHOES BROWN BLACK 11

$62.95
Slide image
GIANVITO ROSSI RET$945 STRAPPY SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 6
GIANVITO ROSSI RET$945 STRAPPY SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 6
GIANVITO ROSSI RET$945 STRAPPY SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 6
New

GIANVITO ROSSI RET$945 STRAPPY SANDAL DESIGNER SHOES GOLD 6

$184.95
Slide image
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
New

JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41

$59.95
Slide image
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES BLACK 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES BLACK 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES BLACK 41
New

JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER BLOCK HEEL SANDAL SHOES BLACK 41

$59.95
Slide image
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER SLINGBACK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER SLINGBACK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER SLINGBACK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41
New

JOSEF SEIBEL LEATHER SLINGBACK HEEL SANDAL SHOES TAN 41

$55.95
Loading...